Hallllooooohhhaaaaaa :D
Kali ini saya mau nge posting paper saya lagi guys, hahaha :D. Ini merupakan paper kedua saya, asyik e :D. Well, paper saya kali ini, motionnya sangat jauh berbeda dengan yang sebelumnya. Kali ini K Fardi (one of my guide) ngasih motion yang berhubungan dengan peperangan dan senjata, waww lumayan bingung juga saya pas pertama kali ngebaca motionnya (aduhhh, selalunya bingung klau ngebaca motion, hahahah :D). Bingung mau set up nih motion di negara mana and alasannya kenapa meski di negara tersebut. Nggak lama kemudian saya langsung teringat dengan konflik korean selatan dan korea utara (maklumlah, saya kan K pop lovers, hahaha :D). Kemudian saya lalu mendapatkan ide buat ngebahas nihh motion. Well, let`s check it out my paper with the motion THBT Countrier have a right to nuclear weapon.
A.
Government
1.
Background
/status quo
Okay, the motion today is this house believe that countrier have a
right to nuclear weapon. And you know this motion means that country or state is
allowed, permitted, has the right and power to make nuclear weapons. Nuclear
weapon is a weapon that the energy comes from nuclear reactions and has a
tremendous power of destruction, a nuclear bomb that can destroy and devastated
a city. Nuclear weapons can be launched through a variety of ways, such as
through bombers, missiles, ballistic missiles and intercontinental ballistic missile. Nuclear weapons has two
basic types, the first type of energy blast only fission reaction process
called atomic bomb. The second type of explosion produces energy through
nuclear fusion reactions or so-called hydrogen bomb.
Status quo now, we know that north Korea and south Korea have
internal conflicts that until now this has not been resolved. North Korea and
South Korea can fought each other and air truce each other. As we know that
North Korea already have nuclear weapons at any time they can use to attack
South Korea. Even, North Korea have a few times gave threats to the south Korea.
So, if North Korea attack South Korea using weapons of nuclear, then certainly
winch South Korea will be crushed like Nagasaki and Hiroshima. Therefor, countries
like South Korea should be given the right to develop and build nuclear weapons
as one of the military defense efforts. This is intended that South Korea to
defend their country because every country have the right and obligation to
protect and defend the country from any case.
There are many benefits obtainable when using nuclear weapons. The benefits
of using nuclear weapon namely, reducing the loss experts, why is that ?
because nuclear weapons can be operated remotely using a tool that can control
it. So that, if an incident occurs like an accident or damage to the weapon
which can cause death then it will not make the experts also wounded. Besides
that, if South Korea used nuclear weapons in war, then the odds of winning will
be greater because, as we know that a potential nuclear weapons has tremendous
destructive power.
2.
Mechanism
a.
Make
a rule that countries can only use nuclear weapons as a form of defense.
b.
Make
a rule nuclear non-proliferation.
3.
Bring
case
a. Countries
like South Korea can use nuclear weapons when other countries attack them
first. For example, North Korea attacked South Korea with use nuclear weapons
then South Korea can also use nuclear weapons to attack North Korea. Why is
that? because nuclear weapons are used as a form of defense to defend the
country. Nuclear weapons are not used to attack other countries in advance or
to master other countries.
b. Countries
with nuclear weapons must sign a nuclear non-proliferation. This agreement
provides that the possession of nuclear weapons a country should be limited.
This agreement has three main points, namely non-proliferation, disarmament,
and the right to use nuclear technology for peaceful purposes.
B.
Opposition
1. Rebuttal
Well, we have two rebuttal for government team. The first is, they
say that there are many benefits of nuclear weapon. We disagree with the
statement. Why? Because more weapons have losses because the explosive power of
nuclear weapons is very high and dangerous, it can kill innocent people. It is
the same as seizing the rights of others to live and continue the descent.
Besides that, among people who definitely killed a lot of children who are
victims. Children who are the future generation of the country. So, who's going
to lead, protect and defend the country in the future.
Nuclear weapons causing radiation. The radiation can be exposed to
the society. If they are exposed to nuclear radiation, it can result in cell
mutations. Mutations are changes in the genetic material (DNA or RNA), both at
the level of gene sequences as well as at the level of the chromosome. Mutations
can causes new diseases and cancer. Treatment for all of diseases must be very
difficult, because there are cells in the human body has undergone mutation. This
need a long time to find the treatment and research process that need very high
cost.
Besides that, nuclear weapons also produce a very thick smoke that
can cause air pollution. If the content of carbon dioxide in the air increases,
global warming will accelerate so that the ozone layer that protects the earth
will be broken.
The last rebuttal for government team is, they say that country
that have a nuclear weapon will not use it for advance or master the other
country. We are not sure about that. Why? Because as we know that, every human
would want something more if they had obtained what they wanted before. It is
the natural instinct of a human being. So if a country have nuclear weapons,
then the country will definitely want to dominate other countries. Because the
country wants to be the strongest country and controls all other countries.
2.
Bring
case
Under the motion we believe that why this motion exist. As we know
that society have a right to defend their country. They have to defend their
country from various disturbances and threats. But not with the use of nuclear
weapons. There are various ways to maintain state. For example, as has been
done in South Korea which requires citizens to military service. Military
service aims to provide the basic skills of the military. Furthermore, country
can increase the defense capabilities by increasing its military members, for
example by conducting training and education. Besides that, the country should
also improve weapons arsenal and replace it with a good quality. Well, we think
that`s all and thank you.
No comments:
Post a Comment